June 2025

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
1516171819 2021
22232425262728
2930     

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Tuesday, November 5th, 2024 08:31 am
How do you perceive genius? Have you ever met a genius face-to-face? Have you carried on a conversation with a genius, gone on a date with one, or lived in a household with one? In most accounts, allowances must be made for genius. In some instances, people would practically bend over backwards (as the saying goes) for a person who was an acknowledged genius. But in the end, it comes down to the question of who/what is genius?

I’ve met a variety of people throughout my 70 years who were considered genius. I can say with certitude that I know none who fit that definition now, although I know creative people who, in some instances, have created works of art within their field that could be considered genius. These were pieces that influenced their type of artwork for many years after their creation.

But what works of genius would you think of if you were asked to define a pinnacle work of genius? As someone who was a musician for more than a decade, my thoughts most often turn to musical genius – the tones, melodies and pure visions that music can create within the human brain while it is listened to. Of the many works I’ve had the joy of hearing, I come back to one stunning and sterling work that I would keep, if I had to give away every other piece of music in my personal collection or in my head. That work? The Ninth Symphony of Ludwig van Beethoven.

Composed between mid-1822 and the end of 1823, it premiered in Vienna’s Theater Kärntnertor on May 7, 1824. The actual notice for the premier was only published the day before the performance, so many who would have packed the audience were away at their country houses, enjoying the early days of summer. There are contradictions about what Beethoven wore, when the first standing ovation occurred; even who conducted the performance. However as it concluded, Michael Umlauf (generally attributed to have been the actual conductor of the orchestra), gently took the composer’s arm while Beethoven was still conducting the musicians, turning him to face the audience – all standing and cheering. It was undoubtedly the first performance of what would become one of the world’s most celebrated pieces of music. The fact that Beethoven never actually heard a single note of the music, doesn’t change the immense gift of music that his brilliance gave to the audience both then and now.

As the daughter of a classically-trained concert pianist and a man who adored opera and musical theater, I was heavily exposed to music as I was growing up. I tried learning the piano – disaster. It wasn’t that I couldn’t learn it – I can still play the keyboard to this day. It was that it simply didn’t sing to me. My cousin Andrea became the pianist in the family, getting an MA in music from Boston University and still, to this day, playing her grand piano daily, before going out to take care of the horses and other livestock on her rural Colorado home.

I, loving music but not the keyboard (although that might have been due to instructors and the ability of my smaller hands to reach much past one octave), changed course. I started playing the cello when I was 10 years old. That became my love until I entered college, when I realized that I wanted to become an archaeologist. I felt that lugging a cello along on a dig would be past ridiculous, so I sacrificed my music for the dirt. But the fact that I no longer played music in no way negated my love for it and my deep love for Beethoven. One of the best things I did for my boyfriend (later to become husband) was introduce him to all nine symphonies of Beethoven. As most people do, he fell in love with them - that incredible musical gift.

Why do we reach for music when we stretch out for something to cling to? In my most unhappy of times, I usually found myself reaching for my collection of Beethoven once again. Any of the Symphonies, or all of them in order, are guaranteed to return stability to me once again. Music gives me hope that people, no matter how silly, self-centered, or evil they can be; people are still capable of extraordinary things. These sounds, these melodies that create visions in the listener, calm my heart, and bring tears to my eyes; these sounds are an auditory confirmation of life itself. Everyone who loves music – any style or type of music – is my brother, my sister, my cousin or my friend. There is commonality between us through the sounds that we listen to and appreciate. It is that love that allows me to love others, both despite and in spite of the silly, stupid and sometimes horrible things that people do.

While the bombs fall on Ukraine, I remind myself that I cannot hate all Russians for the actions of their military. The Russians also gave us Tchaikovsky and Stravinsky. Do I have a problem with the current Chinese dictator? Well, yes, I have a lot of problems with him, but there’s also Tan Dun and Qigong Chen – wonderful composers. So, as we continue to live in a world of strife, perhaps take a serious look at what you like. Literature, music, artwork, it’s all there. It’s still being created by wonderful, talented people who didn’t choose their place of birth. Celebrate the artists instead of condemning the nations in which they reside. If all else fails, recover hope by listening to the symphony that Beethoven never actually heard in real life, only in his head and through the bottoms of his feet as he conducted the orchestra playing his masterpiece.
Tags:
Tuesday, November 5th, 2024 02:59 pm (UTC)
Yes- I met a genius at uni. We were good friends for some time.

Abdulrazek Gurnah who went on to be a truly fine novelist and is now a nobel literature laureate.
Edited 2024-11-05 03:07 pm (UTC)
Wednesday, November 6th, 2024 10:53 am (UTC)
Beautiful, my friend. Thank you for sharing your heart.
Wednesday, November 6th, 2024 12:52 pm (UTC)
A shining light this dismal day. Thank you.
Wednesday, November 6th, 2024 03:34 pm (UTC)
This was wonderful essay, and so clearly written. One of the first things I did once I owned my first not-very-good stereo was to buy a boxed set of all 9 of Beethoven's symphonies. I agree that the Ninth is a work of pure genius. The genius lies in part in the composition of it - how can anyone compose anything so complex and masterful and not be able to hear it as you go along, to hear the voices of all the instruments, the false starts and purely bad parts? But then, the composition of music is something I find almost mystical to begin with. Is there a particular recorded performance of the 9th that you prefer to all others?
Wednesday, November 6th, 2024 03:56 pm (UTC)
Beethoven's 9th remains an entire amazing phenomenon to me. And the fact he put it out there knowing he'd never hear it ... it's heartbreaking and amazing at the same time.
Saturday, November 9th, 2024 03:35 pm (UTC)
So much to comment on here! Our home has always been full of music, classical and modern. Beethoven moves me to tears, Tchaikovsky is a wonder, last spring I had the joy of listening to the Atlanta Symphony perform Rhapsody in Blue live.

My son is currently a music composition major in college. Mother's bias aside, he is incredibly talented. After singing and playing for years, he started composing at the age of 16, pieces that made you FEEL something, and he absolutely loves doing it. It's a beautiful thing to see your child discovering their passions - and being good at them!

When I meet families that don't listen to music much, or adults who don't I wonder at how that is possible to be missing out on such a wonderful, transformative part of life!
Sunday, November 10th, 2024 12:19 am (UTC)
I love Beethoven! And the ninth symphony is my favorite, too.

I have met a genius! One of my hospice patients was an eccentric, millionaire genius inventor. My entire family had used his inventions which delighted him. He was fun to visit. I still miss him. He asked me once if I had ever driven a sports car, and I said, "I owned a Mustang . . ." And he said, "No, I mean a Lamborghini or a Ferrari." And proceeded to tell me about his friend who loaned him his Lamborghini. LOL! I've never even seen a Lamborghini in person (I have seen a Ferrari once) and I don't know anyone who owns one, let alone someone who would let me borrow it. ;)
Sunday, November 10th, 2024 07:42 am (UTC)
My favorite of Beethoven's symphonies is actually the 5th, but the 9th comes second. Amazing piece of work, and to think of composing it while deaf! The voicing of the instruments seems as if it would be the greatest challenge, although I suspect that was always something mentally conjured for all of his orchestral works. He would have to imagine the sound, as he would never actually hear it until the first performance.

I almost wrote a non-fiction entry this week, inspired by the discovery of an unknown Chopin waltz that was announced within the last 2 weeks. That was a genius piece in microcosm.
Monday, November 11th, 2024 06:20 pm (UTC)
I don't much care for Mozart, which is an uncommon opinion. The Classical era was one in which music was often intended to be part of the background, which is not what I'm looking for! I like emotion in music-- fierce, angry, comical, poignant, heartbreaking, wistful sounds. And at least SOME dissonance, usually. So, I love the Romantics (Beethoven is the beginning of that), the Impressionists, and the 20th-century Neo-Romantics.

Mozart is rarely any of those things. The pieces that have one or more of those aspects tend to be the ones of his works which I enjoy more. ;)
Monday, November 11th, 2024 05:52 pm (UTC)
I love this! Music was my absolute first love (from the crib according to my mom I cried for the radio to be turned on, and would dance and sing before walking and talking).
I'm a musician too and love many sorts of music including classical which I really adore. Beethoven is one of my favorite composers!
Monday, November 11th, 2024 07:12 pm (UTC)
Well said. You mentioned that we reach for music to cling to. I always have as well. Music speaks to me in ways little else does. You can usually always find music that will speak to what you are feeling in any given moment. It is evocative and stirring. Be it Beethoven or Pink Floyd, music just encapsulates feeling. Thought. It stirs the soul.

Very well said. Your piece resonates with me.
Tuesday, November 12th, 2024 05:14 am (UTC)
I'm thrilled to go another week in this incredible group of writers.

I feel exactly the same way.